Friday, January 21, 2011

What’s So Great About Christianity

My review of Dinesh D’Souza’s book, on Amazon:

Dinesh D'Souza is a battle-hardened Christian apologist who has taken on such notable atheists as Christopher Hitchens, Michael Shermer, Daniel Dennett, and Peter Singer all recorded for posterity on YouTube. A notable characteristic of each debate is that his opponents have all been extremely congratulatory of D'Souza, they've actually walked away licking some wounds!

Of course, before picking up this book, I did not know any of this. D'Souza has long been a favorite author and I was surprised to see he'd written such a book so I picked it up to find a well-written collection of a case for Christianity, based solely on logic and science. He promises this right out of the gate and stuck to this promise throughout the book: no revelatory expositions, no pointing at this or that Bible verse. He writes on page 11, for example, that his "modus operandi is one of skepticism, to view the claims of religion in the same open-minded way that we would view claims of any other sort. The difference," he continues, "between me and my atheist opponents is that I am skeptical not only of the allegedly irrational claim of religion but also of the irrational claims made in the name of science and of skepticism itself."

Like a prosecuting attorney building a case against atheism, D'Souza deftly and succinctly handles all the most important questions raised by the New Atheists: the question of evolution, the question of evil (how can a good God exist in the face of such evil), the question of an objective morality not dependent on opinion, the veracity and historicity of the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Chapter 15 in particular (The World Beyond Our Senses: Kant and the Limits of Reason) is a brilliant precise of how we know what we know and whether we can trust it.

All this combines to make a strong case that religious faith in general and Christianity in particular is not altogether unreasonable and that while there are no absolute proofs on its side, the skeptical atheist also bears the burden of proof, only this time of proving that God doesn't exist. A burden, he surmises, they cannot rationally support. In the end, 'What's So Great About Christianity' did end up proving certain things: that D'Souza here, as always, is a steadfast good writer of formidable intelligence, a fact attested to by none other than Christopher Hitchens on several occasions. That the religion of Christianity doesn't require blind, unthinking faith and is thoroughly defensible against atheistic and secular attacks and that we today live in a world positively molded by the tenets of Christianity.

For the budding Christian apologist setting out on the path, this book sits high on the list of recommended titles. Those who understand the basics can then move on to William Lane Craig's [[ASIN:1433501155 Reasonable Faith: Christian Truth and Apologetics]]. Be careful however, for this is an area of philosophy that is not only fascinating beyond belief (no pun intended), but also rigorous.

Highest recommendations.

No comments: