Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Same Old Song & Dance (With A Twist)

Ricky Gervais is not funny.

That is not to say he’s always been that way. Way back, in the original (and best) The Office era, his middle name was ‘hilarious’ then something happened. I speculate it could be when he got famous or when he sold The Office to American TV, but he became most assuredly not funny.

This diagnosis was confirmed beyond a shadow after I’d seen HBO’s Ricky Gervais: Out of England. That stumbling, diffused babbling of a show underscored it: the man’s no longer funny and I can forgive almost anything in my celebrities … but that.

And now, as if to seal himself into the unfunny tomb for eternity, Gervais puts pen to paper and writes A Holiday Message from Ricky Gervais: Why I’m An Atheist for the Wall Street Journal. Now as atheistic missives to the world go (one wonders why they’re constantly proselytizing—if nothing objectively and truly matters, why bother?) it’s a very different, i.e. smellier beast from Bertrand Russell’s. In fact, it’s terrible.

First, it’s not funny.

Second, it’s replete with threadbare atheistic tropes (“science can’t prove God’s existence therefore He doesn’t exist”, “I believe in one less god than you do,” “you don’t need God to be moral,” etc.) and that’s really tiresome. That someone who really cares intellectually—in other words, a real skeptic—won’t seek to do the basic work necessary to answer these Grand Questions smacks of intellectual laziness and worse, hubris. At the very least, a true skeptic will arrive at agnosticism rather than atheism (see Kant, Immanuel; also Pascal, Blaise).

However, the shocker of the article was a recounting by Gervais of his eight-year-old self rejecting theism and the existence of God within an hour of being asked “Why do you believe in God?” by his self-described maladjusted brother. Atheism: so easy an eight-year-old could do it in an hour.

How utterly ridiculous.

And how not funny.

No comments: