Here’s a particularly interesting passage from Malcolm Gladwell’s book, Outliers.
… throughout history, not surprisingly, the people who grew rice have always worked harder than almost any other kind of farmer.
That last statement may seem a little odd, because most of us have a sense that everyone in the premodern world worked really hard. But that simply isn’t true. All of us, for example, are descended at some point from hunter-gatherers, and many hunter-gatherers, by all accounts, had a pretty leisurely life. The !Kung bushmen of the Kalahari Desert, in Botswana, who are one of the last remaining practitioners of that way of life, subsist on a rich assortment of fruits, berries, roots, and nuts—in particular, the mongongo nut, an incredibly plentiful and protein-rich source of food tha lies thick on the ground. They don’t grow anything, and it is growing things—preparing, planting, weeding, harvesting, storing—that takes time. Nor do they raise any animals.
Occasionally, the male !Kung hunt, but chiefly for sport. All told, !Kung men and women work no more than about twelve to nineteen hours a week, with the balance of the time spent dancing, entertaining, and visiting family and friends. That’s, at most, one thousand hours of work a year. (When a bushman was asked once why his people hadn’t taken to agriculture, he looked puzzled and said, “Why should we plant, when there are so many mongongo nuts in the world?”)
This is rather incredible if you think about it. When I was in High School, I remember trying to understand the differences between the life I lived in Nigeria (squalor, terrible conditions really) and that I’d seen in other countries I’d visited (the United Kingdom, mostly).
To my rudimentary way of thinking at that time, I hit upon something that I thought may perhaps explain that difference: people in that part of Africa actually lived in what can arguably be described as a natural Garden of Eden. The soil provided amply without too much need for cultivation beyond clearing the land for tilling and perhaps, from time to time, fertilization. But for the most part, all you had to do was put a hole in the ground, throw in a seed and soon you’d have a wildly successful harvest with really minimal upkeep work.
Contrast this with all the work a European or New World farmer would have to do to prepare the land after Winter. All those climatological pressures requires work and a measure of ingenuity. The land simply had to be coaxed into production. I thought, at the time, that this difference may account for why one culture needfully progressed at a faster rate than the other.
To provide an even greater contrast in this theme, this time between the West and the East, particularly China with its thousands of years of cultivating paddies, Gladwell discusses how Chinese farmers had to build rice paddies, unlike wheat fields which were simply “opened up.”
“You just don’t clear the trees, underbrush, and stones and then plow. Rice fields are carved into moutainsides in an elaborate series of terraces, or painstakingly constructed from marshland and river plains. A rice paddy has to be irrigated, so a complex system of dikes has to be built around the field. Channels must be dug from the nearest water source, and gates built into the dikes so the water flow can be adjusted precisely to cover the right amount of the plant.
The paddy itself, meanwhile, has to have a hard clay floor; otherwise the water will simply seep into the ground. But of course, rice seedlings can’t be planted in hard clay, so on top of the clay, there has to be a thick, soft layer of much. And the claypan, as it’s called, has to be carefully engineered so that it will drain properly and also keep the plants submerged at the optimum level. Rice has to be fertilized repeatedly, which is another art. Traditionally, farmers used “night soil” (human manure) and a combination of burned compost, river mud, bean cake, and hemp—and they had to be careful, because too much fertilizer, or the right amount applied at the wrong time, could be as bad as too little.
When the time came to plant, a Chinese farmer would have hundreds of different varieties of rice from which to choose, each one of which offered a slightly different trade-off, say, between yield and how quickly it grew, or how well it did in times of drought, or how it fared in poor soil. A farmer might plan a dozen or more different varietals at one time, adjusting the mix from season to season in order to manage the risk of a crop failure.”
So there you go, my schoolboy theories may have actually had some credence. I kind of feel good about that. The latter example is used in Outliers to explain one of the reasons Chinese people are, or seem to be, better at Math than Westerners: hard, unstinting work borne out of years of cultural training due to geographical factors.
No comments:
Post a Comment