Sunday, January 06, 2008

A Fisking

Joshua James fisked me on his blog.  I decided not to continue the "conversation" because I did start it with a snide remark, something I've apologized for.  I don't want to take up space on his blog arguing about this there, so I'm fisking his fisk of me here:

My comments in RED.

Now for some heavy duty fisking -

“Hah! I like the non sequitor references to our dear old homosexual senator. Nice. You must be a writer or something.”

Uh, ya think?

 

You did get that I was being facetious, right?


“To get your train off the Straw Man rails and back on track: I’ve never talked about President Bush to your knowledge, but if it soothes you any, I agree: the president has wasted his mandate. He’s a fuck up, in re Conservative principles. For me however, better him that The Goracle and definitely better him than Kerry.”

In terms of what he’s done to the Justice department, to the Constitution (which the Republican Party would have NEVER allowed a democratic President to do) he certainly WASN’T better. He was hired, in a sense, to protect and defend the constitution. Not only did he NOT do that, he broke federal law. So that’s more than a fuckup, that’s criminal, and to state that a man of your political party who engaged in such criminal activity is better than Gore or Kerry (two candidates whom I didn’t care for, especially Kerry) is not only extremely misguided, if one calls themself a conservative, it’s also hypocritical.

So, that’s you.

H’m. Sticks and stones… well, there are two things we’ll never know for sure (thank God) and that’s what either of those two twits would have done in office. Say what you will about President Bush, if he’d broken any laws, those swirling masses of Hammerheads (AKA dimwit Democratic Congress pussies) would have taken him down. That didn’t happen and that will never happen. Sorry old boy.

“As it so happens, I was in Florida in 2000, and voted for Bush. I know how much you really want to believe the nonsense about Bush stealing the election, but sorry old boy, it just ain’t true. Alas, there’ll be nothing I can say that’ll change your mind, so let’s leave it at that.”

Hmm, well, in term of Straw Man arguments, this takes the cake. Firstly, if you voted for Bush in FL, we certainly don’t agree on Bush. Secondly, the election WAS stolen, just not by you.

By the Supreme Court, by “activist judges” appointed by one of the candidate’s OWN FATHER.

The man who lost the election took office. The man who lost the popular vote took office. It was given to him by Judge’s appointed by his father. That’s stolen. From the people.

How the hell can you call yourself conservative or American and not stand up for the right of a democratic majority? boggles the mind, but you bet, we won’t agree on this. I tend to side on the ideals set forth by the founding fathers and the constitution.

You do understand what a Straw Man argument is, don’t you? When we began this little tango, I didn’t bring up the President at all. I called you on the aberrant title you gave yourself as a so-called Independent. Instead of staying in that ball park, you completely switched the game and started in on attacking President Bush. That is the classic example of a Straw Man argument.

This knee-jerk love of conspiracy theories is one of the foremost symptoms of liberal derangement syndrome. Believe whatever fantastical, convoluted theory you want. I believe I’ll stay away from following you into the dank cave of illogic that you liberals like to live in.

“There’s no such thing as a Conservative Party. To me, there are only conservative (by which I mean Reaganite, if that makes sense) principles. The Republican Party has left a lot of those principles in the gutter and I’m pissed off about that. However, better a smidgen of whatever conservative principles there are left in the Republican Party than the poxy Socialist Marxism alternatives the modern Democratic Party espouses. Any time, any day.”

Wow. Where to begin? Well, if there isn’t a Conservative Party, why don’t you tell the Republican party that, the ones running on that mandate? They’ve certainly taken that mantle, so I don’t see how you can make that argument. They are the conservative party because that’s what they claim to be.

Oh really? They are because they say they are? Do you see where the use of your kind of logic can end up? If you’re so easily inclined to take the Republicans at their word, why don’t you vote for them next year? ;-)

Now where we might agree is that they don’t act “conservative”, ie, smaller government, support the constitution, etc. There, you may be right. That goes back to Reagan as well, in a bad way. That just makes them hypocrites. Which I pointed out before, and given your stance earlier, you’re comfortable with.

Nothing going back to Reagan is bad. Everything about Reagan is good. Viva la Reagan revolucion!

There certainly is a conservative movement, espoused by the conservative think-tanks the Heritage Foundation, etc. So this is bull.

And the idea that we’ve been better off the past eight years, with a “conservative president (whom you just stated you prefer over Gore or Kerry) is ridiculous. Just our debt alone is enough to debunk that load of horse-hoey.

Like I said, we’ll never know. And thank God for that.

“As for my so-called racism, you really need to understand what it means to be one. First, there’s a huge difference between discrimination, prejudice and racism and one does not follow the others in whatever combination. Second, according to the only dictionary worth its salt (OED), racism is the theory that distinctive human characteristics and abilities are determined by race. Using this definition, it’s easy to state I am not a racist. What I am is biased: I think the philosophy of the modern liberal is defunct, bankrupt, and more than that, dangerous.”

So I don’t have a “race”? That’s ridiculous. Of course I do.
I don’t check “NA” Not-Applicable” on my forms when it asks for race. I am compelled to check Caucasian.

Huh? Read closer, playwright: I said, it’s easy [for me] to state I [Fred] am not a racist.

Now whether or not your bias is based on racial principles or not, I don’t know. It’s certainly possible for someone to say racist things without being racist, just like it’s possible for someone to be racist without ever uttering a word. I told you what you wrote, talking about Barack and Monkeys, felt racist. The fact you are mix-raced doesn’t mean what you wrote wasn’t racist, you base that on what you said and did. Felt racist, to me.

That’s the problem with you liberals, always feeling things and letting those feelings get you into trouble. It’s the same problem with all those idiots who decided to buy houses they couldn’t afford, because it just felt so good to buy a house. Brilliant.

yeah, we all have biases. you bet. Some are reasonable, some are not. Discriminating against people for what they choose to believe can be common sense (like, I’d never employ a Klan member because of what they choose to believe) but discriminating against someone for how they were born is not, it’s unethical. You used code, attacking Barack for one thing (his “liberal” beliefs) while employing the tools of another (monkeys, do I have to explain that) so there you have it.

Hah! I used “code” did I? And you, sir, you have the code breaking Racial Enigma Machine in your back room, do you? See where feelings will get you?

And damn, man. Conservative government (and that’s what Bush, the guy you voted for and preferred over Kerry and Gore, says he practices) has FUCKED up this country for the last 8 years and most of all, pissed all over the constitution. So your argument that liberal government is dangerous and conservative government is not has a severe problem with empirical evidence - in other words, what we’re seeing with our own damn eyes.

Luckily, most of America has seen it as well, so the conservative party is being repudiated not only by independents and young people, but by many Republicans themselves.

Again, there is no such thing as the conservative party. Speculating on what those two morons would have done to this country causes shivers of dread to shoot up my spine. I’m just happy that we’ll never ever know what that disaster would have been like. I’m sure that your life is so much worse off now than when the President began his tenure 8 years ago. If so, you’re either a liar or a liberal or both. Probably both. Whatever the case, I won’t be called to argue what one of those idiots would have done as opposed to what has been done.

Just to keep you honest though, the reason Republicans didn't win the mid-term elections is because those of us conservatives didn't show up--we were pissed off at the people we voted in to office earlier.  Not because of some great victory Democrats won or some other fundamental sea-change.  This is why you liberals are always going to be shocked every time you lose, you just never learn .  There are more conservative people in America today than you liberals, packed as you are into the high rise rat race cages you call your cities.

“As an aside, allow me: you are is also biased and heavily so. We both are, for the very human fact that we are indeed human, bigots. Yours just happens to ensconce itself in the prevalent politically correct soft pillows of overly emotional good intentions.”

Good intentions, whether hard or soft, are not bad things. Basically you’re saying that because I have good intentions, I’m soft, and that you are not soft because you don’t have good intentions?

You’ve never heard of the aphorism that the road to hell is paved with good intentions, then? Since you’ve badly failed to grasp what it is I am saying, let me be clear(er):

You’re biased.

You’re a bigot.

You’re prejudiced.

Just like me.

You just happen to feel better about yourself because you think your biases, your bigotry and prejudice aren’t as bad because all your intentions are good. Well, let me tell you something: intentions, even the best intentions, not based on hard logic and a grasp of reality will end up hurting everyone. Look at Welfare.

I admit to being biased against ignorance and racism, theocracy, you bet. I’m not bigoted, which has to do with race and birthright and things other than an individual’s choice.

Here’s a dictionary definition of bigotry: Irrational suspicion or hatred of a particular group, race, or religion.

If casting the sort of aspersions you’re so comfortable doing isn’t bigotry, I don’t know what is.

“I will resort to vituperation and hyperbole to prove and ridicule it; interestingly, as YOU also do.

What I don’t do is indulge in prejudicial, discriminative behavior. I cannot afford to do otherwise–I’m half-black, half-white. Understand, everyone’s an asshole until they prove differently. Even then, I don’t behave any differently toward them, regardless of how retarded I think they are. I believe in the power of rhetoric backed by the even more overwhelming power of logic.”

Right. But I think your logic is suspect, as is your use of, what looked to me to be, somewhat racist language. Understand, language and its code words (there are many, welfare mothers, used by Reagan, being one of the most famous) is not an exact science, but it is something to be parsed out logically, words and their effects and ideas behind them. That’s what philosophy is about, after all, parsing those out.

Thank you for taking on the mantle of being the arbiter of what is and isn’t racism. I’m sure the International Council of American Racism Everywhere (I CARE) will appreciate it—how enlightened of you. In case you don’t know, I’m being sarcastic.

Again, the fact that you are half-black doesn’t mean you get a free pass on racist words, just like I don’t. You’re free to use them, as am I, we’re free to say what we want and free to call bullshit on what we want. I called bullshit on it and you called it back. I don’t think you’re using logic, though. The fact of your race doesn’t mean you cannot be racist. You can. I can. Bush can. Anybody can, based on their actions. Color doesn’t mean you can’t be.

Just like the fact that Larry Craig is gay doesn’t mean he cannot be homophobic. He’s obviously both.

Another Straw Man. Where did I say that I cannot be racist? I asked if it was possible. You said yes. In fact, to be clear, what I was asking is, is it possible to be a racist against someone of the exact same race? Calling a half-black, half-white man a monkey is calling myself a monkey.

“There are many things I believe that are in direct contravention of what the modern Republican Party believes, and shockingly, more in line with mainstream Democratic Party beliefs. In other words, I think about things, vigorously investigate theories then I make up my mind.

Like when I agree with you about President Bush.”

We don’t agree about Bush, not if you prefer the job he’s done thus far over the job Gore or Kerry might have done, not at all. And I feel about the Dem party much like you do the Republicans . . . The Dem’s are too much like Republicans, and not enough like they need to be to get this country on the right track and most of all, not break fucking federal laws. That’s it, really. The Republican Party has proven again and again they’ll break federal laws.

Again, simply screaming that someone’s broken a law doesn’t mean anything except a lot of hot air which contributes to that mythical Global Warming. If the ENTIRE Republican Party has broken federal laws, please do prosecute them, why don’t you?

as much as I dislike Dem’s, and I do in many ways, they haven’t been criminal as the Republican party and anyone who doesn’t see that is seriously deluding themselves, really.

If your brand of dislike is reflected in your loving paean to all their candidates, I’d really hate to see what you think of those you hate. Oh right, you’ve already shown that: Fuck The Republicans. Seriously, fuck those guys. Nice.

And I’m open to discussion and logic, but really Fred, I don’t see us doing that, do you? We’re just fisking each other, and you’re determined not to listen to me and I’m pretty sure I don’t get what logic you’re speaking of, so maybe we should call it quits. You’re free to believe what you wish, as I am, but I didn’t come to your blog to try and convince you of anything . . . you came here, first, and made a somewhat snide comment on my status as an independent.

No comments: