Friday, July 27, 2007

Socialized Medicine

I grew up in Nigeria, a country where one is supposedly taken care of by the government, from cradle to grave. For free.

The only problem is, the length of time between cradle and grave is despondingly small, if the government-run hospitals have anything to do about it. Socialized healthcare is dangerous. I know because it let my mother die.

She was taken to the hospital in Benin City, Edo state about a year ago. She arrived to find there were no doctors. There were no nurses on duty either. She died as she was on her way—in a taxi—to a “clinic,” as private hospitals are known there.

In all the time I lived in Nigeria, while it was true I never paid to go to a hospital, I also never actually needed medical help. I was in general good health, suffering nothing more serious than the “normal” Third World childhood problems such as Malaria, Dysentery, and once, splitting my toe open with an axe (don't ask). The few times I did have to go in, it was always to visit one of those clinics which, being private, actually had medical personnel on duty and passably good care. And of course, we had to pay.

I did one time have to visit the hospital for a dental appointment. When we arrived, we were seated with about 50 people in what seemed like the antechamber to an execution chamber. Heart-quickening screams would sporadically emanate from somewhere as we would-be patients nervously glanced around, wondering whether the pain wracking our mouths was bearable enough to hightail it out of there. All to see two dentists.

We did not return and my teeth today aren't in the best shape because of it. When the inevitable toothaches occurred, my brother, my mom and I would lie in bad, popping pain pills, drenched in sweat and rolling from side to side, cursing life.

I have some good friends who trained in Nigeria as doctors, one especially who lives in Birmingham, UK. On a visit there some years ago, he regaled me with stories of the things he'd done as a medical student, including, incredibly, being an assistant surgeon on a woman patient who almost died because the lead surgeon had wanted to cut some vital vessel and was only stopped at the last moment by my friend. That woman would have died and a convenient story would have been concocted for the family, who no doubt would have blamed some voodoo curse. Because, you know, doctors in Third World countries are infallible.

There were more such stories, each one more horrendous than the other. And the patients? The ones who were getting operated on by medical students barely old enough to shave? They never paid a dime (or kobo, as the case may be.)

One may contend that Nigeria's is a very bad example to use as a case against socialized medicine, and I'd agree, to a point. Places like Canada also suffer from the inevitable problems accompanying anything government-run.

In this article, Dr. Jacques Chaoulli recounts overcrowded emergency rooms, months' long waiting lists for radiation treatment for women with breast cancer, the man with persistent pain from a hernia operation who doctors referred to a pain clinic where he ran into a waiting list three years' long!

The Brits aren't much better: the recent controversy around the cancer patient who tried to get an appointment with a specialist, only to have it canceled—48 times. From the article:

More than 1 million Britons must wait for some type of care, with 200,000 in line for longer than six months. In France, the supply of doctors is so limited that during an August 2003 heat wave — when many doctors were on vacation and hospitals were stretched beyond capacity — 15,000 elderly citizens died. Across Europe, state-of-the-art drugs aren't available. And so on.

Another excerpt about recent happenings in Canada:

Consider, too, Rick Baker. He isn't a neurosurgeon or even a doctor. He's a medical broker — one member of a private sector that is rushing in to address the inadequacies of Canada's government care. Canadians pay him to set up surgical procedures, diagnostic tests and specialist consultations, privately and quickly.

Baker describes a man who had a seizure and received a diagnosis of epilepsy. Dissatisfied with the opinion — he had no family history of epilepsy, but he did have constant headaches and nausea, which aren't usually seen in the disorder — he requested an MRI.

The government told him that the wait would be 4 1/2 months. So he went to Baker, who arranged to have the MRI done within 24 hours — and who, after the test revealed a brain tumor, arranged surgery within a few weeks.

Read the rest, it's a story of broken systems, fraught with inefficiency and detritus, the normal attendants of socialism. So, when I hear about people like Hilldog Clinton and Michael Moore advocating the very system that doesn't work anywhere else, I see red and I'm afraid my only response is a quick “fuck off!”

No comments: